Promti or Carrd: two one-page sites, made very differently
Carrd builds one-page sites — “simple, free, fully responsive one-page sites for pretty much anything”, in its own words. You stack text, pictures, buttons and forms in its editor, publish for free on a carrd.co address, and pay a yearly Pro plan, from US$9, for more sites, your own domain, forms and payments.
Promti makes one page as well, but it arrives finished: one of four kits, each made for one kind of subject — something you sell, somewhere people stay, an app, a portfolio — around a 3D scene. You answer a wizard, watch the page become yours, pay once and download the files.
So the question isn’t one page or several. It’s what the page should be: on Carrd, a clean page you lay out yourself for very little; with Promti, a 3D page that is already designed, for €500.
Side by side
| — | Promti | Carrd |
|---|---|---|
| How you pay | €500, a single time. Promti never bills you again. | By the year, in US dollars, with no monthly option: Pro Lite $9, Pro Standard $19 and Pro Plus $49, for 3, 10 and 25 sites. Its terms quote fees without VAT. |
| Free to start | The wizard is free: your site is built there in full, previewed at phone and computer size, and the charge comes with the download. | A free Basic plan: three sites of up to 50 elements each, on a carrd.co address with “Made with Carrd” in the footer. Pro can be tried for seven days, with no card. |
| What you get | The kit’s page with your content in it — name, texts, colours, links — plus your model, photos, screenshots or project pictures, depending on the kit. | An editor with templates or a blank page, hosting with SSL, and the pieces — text, images, video, buttons, forms — for you to arrange. |
| Hosting and domain | The folder goes on any static host; the guide uses Cloudflare Pages’ free plan. A domain is about €10–15 a year. | Carrd hosts it. A domain of your own needs Pro Standard or above and has to be registered elsewhere: Carrd names Cloudflare, Namecheap and Porkbun. |
| Pages | A single page, with a legal page and one for broken links next to it. | A single page as well. Named sections can be linked and switched between to simulate several pages, as its docs put it. |
| Forms | Studio has a contact form that sends through Web3Forms, free up to 250 messages a month; the other kits end on a button to buy, book or get the app. | Contact and sign-up forms from Pro Standard, to your email or to one of 20 mailing services; custom forms with file uploads on Pro Plus. |
| Selling | Buttons to your Stripe payment link — one product in Product, up to four plans in App — or to your booking page. No cart. | Stripe, PayPal and Gumroad buttons from Pro Standard, each with your own account, and forms that take a Stripe payment on Pro Plus. |
| Motion and 3D | Scrolling moves you through a scene drawn live by three.js: the 3D is the page itself, not a block placed on it. | Element animations, animated slideshows and background video. Its pages don’t mention 3D; the Embed element, from Pro Standard, takes your own HTML, CSS and JavaScript. |
| The files | The whole site as a zip from the first download: HTML, CSS and JS, your pictures, the typefaces. | Pro Plus downloads a site’s unminified HTML, CSS and JS. Forms don’t work in the download, and it can’t be uploaded back to Carrd. |
| When the plan ends | There’s no plan to end. The files keep working for as long as they’re hosted. | If a renewal can’t be paid, the account drops to the free plan after a short grace period, and its sites lose their Pro features. |
| Languages | English or Spanish, one per site, picked in the wizard. | One language per site, set in its settings; its docs don’t describe a site in two languages. Carrd’s own pages are in English. |
| Help | A guide for each step after the download, and a 30-minute call with Eric. | Its documentation, a contact form and email; replies usually come within 24 hours, its contact page says. |
Promti fits when…
- The page has to do the impressing on its own, with your product, your place, your app or your work moving in 3D.
- You’d rather fill in a page that’s designed than design one: words, colours, pictures, done.
- You want the legal page, the sitemap and the guides for a domain, an email address and Google to come with the site.
- You want the files from the first day, hosted wherever you choose, rather than a plan to renew each year.
- You want to see the finished page, with your words in it, before any money changes hands.
Carrd fits when…
- Price decides it: US$19 a year buys your own domain, forms and payment buttons.
- You run several small sites — a link page, an event, a sign-up — and want them in one account: plans go from 3 to 1,000 sites.
- You want to lay out the page yourself, element by element, and change it any day in the editor.
- Your form has to feed a mailing tool such as Mailchimp or beehiiv, or take file uploads.
- You want something online today without paying at all: the free plan publishes three sites.
What each costs
Promti: €500, paid one time. Hosting on Cloudflare’s free plan adds nothing, and a domain adds around €10–15 each year: €500 and one domain fee for the first year, €500 and some €30–45 of domain fees by the end of the third.
Carrd, in US dollars as its pricing page shows them, billed yearly, with VAT on top according to its terms: a site on your own domain with a form needs Pro Standard, $19 a year, or $57 over three years, plus the domain you register elsewhere. Pro Plus, for downloading the code or taking payments through a form, is $49 a year, $147 over three. The free plan costs nothing, on a carrd.co address with Carrd’s branding.
On money alone, Carrd is the cheaper way to have a one-page site by a wide margin. What the difference buys is the page itself: on Carrd you design it; with Promti it comes designed, around a 3D scene.
Questions
- Can Carrd make a 3D site?
- Carrd’s pages don’t mention 3D. Its Embed element, from Pro Standard, accepts your own HTML, CSS and JavaScript almost anywhere on a site, so a scene made elsewhere would have to come in that way — and making it, and making it work on phones, would be your job. In a Promti kit the 3D comes first, and everything else is laid out around it.
- Can I download a Carrd site and host it myself?
- On Pro Plus, US$49 a year: Carrd lets you download a site’s unminified HTML, CSS and JS. Its docs warn that forms, which need Carrd to work, won’t function in the download, and that a downloaded site can’t go back into Carrd. With Promti the download is the site: a folder you can host anywhere, where Studio’s form keeps working, because Web3Forms sends it.
- Can either one have several pages?
- Both are one page. Carrd simulates pages with sections you can link to and switch between; a Promti site is one page plus its legal page. If you need real pages — one for each service, a blog — a builder such as Wix or Squarespace suits you better than either, and one page or several helps you decide.
- What happens to a Carrd site if I stop paying?
- According to Carrd’s terms, when a renewal can’t be paid, the account goes back to the free Basic plan after a short grace period, and its sites lose the Pro features they use — a custom domain and forms among them. Promti has nothing to renew: the site stays wherever you host it.
- Can I try both for free?
- Yes. Carrd has a free plan with three sites and a seven-day Pro trial that doesn’t ask for a card. Promti’s wizard costs nothing to use: the whole site gets made there, previewed as a phone and a computer would show it, and payment only comes in at the download.